Künast versus Meta: Does Facebook have to delete false quotes of its own accord?

Published on: February 19.2025Categories: Working world, LegalReading time: 3 min.
künast
Avatar photo
Kilian Floß writes blog articles on legal and current topics for the Love & Law Blog.

The hunt for false quotations: Who bears the responsibility?

In the digital age, we are confronted daily with the danger of false information being spread. Memes that go viral with images and false statements are particularly dangerous. One prominent example of the consequences of such fake news is the Green Party politician Renate Künast. She has now taken legal action against the Meta Group, Facebook's parent company, before the Federal Court of Justice. The reason: a meme that she had falsely quoted spread rapidly online. Künast is demanding that Facebook not only deletes the original post, but also all identical copies - automatically.

Misquotes online: a problem for credibility

In the case of Renate Künast, it's about a quote that she never said: "Integration starts with you learning Turkish as a German!" This sentence has nothing to do with the politician, but it has been circulating on Facebook for years. Even though she reported the post and Facebook deleted it, the quote remains online in many other memes and posts. The solution? Künast demands that Facebook not only reacts to the first reported post, but also proactively searches for and deletes all other similar content.

The challenge for Meta: Is meme deletion even possible?

Facebook is not so sure about this responsibility. The company argues that it is technically almost impossible to find all identical memes and posts. A manual review of millions of posts would be too time-consuming. But the plaintiff's side sees things differently: Facebook, which has the necessary technology, is perfectly capable of identifying content automatically. The case could therefore have far-reaching consequences - not only for politicians, but also for all those who fall victim to hate and false information online.

Künast's fight against fakes: a turning point for the rights of internet users?

The legal dispute has the potential to redefine the rules for dealing with false information on social platforms. If the Federal Court of Justice rules in Künast's favor, this could not only have an impact on politics, but also on all social media users who are confronted with insults and defamation.

Künast's fight for truth

Will Meta finally be held accountable? The ruling could be a milestone in the fight against fake news and online hate - if it prevails. But here's the catch: are we really heading into a future where social networks actually actively look out for us? Meta says it's a technical challenge - but isn't that exactly what we should expect from the big tech companies? If the responsibility for deleting false information remains solely with the users, nothing will ever change on the web. This must come to an end!

Find out how this ruling strengthens your rights online. Get legal advice now and protect your online reputation!

At a fixed price of 119 EURO (gross)